本文已被:浏览 55次 下载 245次
投稿时间:2023-06-25 修订日期:2024-05-06
投稿时间:2023-06-25 修订日期:2024-05-06
中文摘要: 利用2019—2021年2—4月北京地区国家级气象台站逐3 h观测资料,基于统计分析方法对欧洲中期天气预报中心全球数值模式(ECMWF)、中国气象局全球区域同化预报系统(CMA-GFS)以及智能网格预报国家级指导报(SCMOC)、国省融合预报(SMERGE)的温度预报开展了精细化检验评估。结果表明,ECMWF和CMA-GFS对北京春季的温度预报多出现负偏差,且山区和平原地区无明显差异,但在夜间更加突出。SCMOC和SMERGE对温度预报有较好订正能力,温度预报平均误差集中在-1~1℃,温度预报准确率较高且平均绝对误差也较小。四种产品对于24 h变温以及日内昼夜温差的预报存在问题为:所有产品对强变温的变化幅度预报不足,且智能网格预报产品也未体现明显的订正能力;此外,所有产品对昼夜温差幅度的预报存在1~3℃的正偏差,SCMOC有一定订正能力,而SMERGE高估昼夜温差的情况更突出。模式预报昼夜温差偏大与低温(05时温度)预报偏低密切相关,而智能网格预报的高温(14时)预报偏高也不容忽视。通过精细化检验分析,说明智能网格预报在关注整体准确率提升(平均绝对误差,减小)的同时,还应关注天气过程发展演变特征。
中文关键词: 精细化检验,偏差特征,日变化,过程演变,温度预报
Abstract:Using the 3 h observation data from national-level stations in Beijing Region in spring (February to April) during 2019-2021, we evaluate the temperature forecasts made by numerical models including European Centre for Medium-Range Weather Forecasting (ECMWF) and Global and Regional Assimilation and Prediction System (CMA-GFS), and by national gridded guidance forecast product (SCMOC) as well as the revised feedback gridded forecast product at provincial level (SMERGE). The results show that the spring temperature forecasts in Beijing by the models of ECMWF and CMA-GFS often show negative biases. The biases have no significant difference in mountainous and plain areas, but more prominent during nighttime periods. The gridded forecast products (SCMOC and SMERGE) have a good ability to correct the temperature forecasted by the models (ECMWF and CMA-GFS). The temperature forecast biases of the gridded products are concentrated in the range of -1-1℃, meanwhile the forecast accuracy is higher and the mean absolute error is lower than that of model forecast. Some problems are found in the forecasts of 24 h temperature change and diurnal temperature range from the four products. The amplitude of intense 24 h temperature change forecasted by all products is relatively smaller than that of observation, and the gridded forecast products fail to demonstrate significant correction ability. In addition, the diurnal temperature range forecasted by all products has a positive deviation of 1-3℃ compared to the observation. SCMOC has a better correction ability for the diurnal temperature range by the models, while SMERGE overestimates the difference more prominently than that by models. The positive deviation of diurnal temperature range forecast is closely related to the underestimation of low temperature at 05:00 BT in the models, while the overestimation of high temperature at 14:00 BT can not be ignored in the grid forecasts. The refined analysis suggests that gridded forecast products should not only focus on improving overall accuracy (reducing biases), but also on the development and evolution of synoptic processes.
keywords: refined evaluation, bias characteristic, diurnal cycle, process evolution, temperaure forecast
文章编号: 中图分类号:P456,P457 文献标志码:
基金项目:国家重点研发计划(2021YFC3000904)资助
作者 | 单位 |
李妮娜 | 国家气象中心,北京 100081 |
刘凑华 | 国家气象中心,北京 100081 |
林建 | 国家气象中心,北京 100081 |
代刊 | 国家气象中心,北京 100081 |
韦青 | 国家气象中心,北京 100081 |
赵声蓉 | 国家气象中心,北京 100081 |
引用文本:
李妮娜,刘凑华,林建,代刊,韦青,赵声蓉,2024.2019—2021年北京春季温度预报的精细化检验评估[J].气象,50(11):1397-1408.
LI Nina,LIU Couhua,LIN Jian,DAI Kan,WEI Qing,ZHAO Shengrong,2024.Refined Evaluation of Spring Temperature Forecast in Beijing During 2019-2021[J].Meteor Mon,50(11):1397-1408.
李妮娜,刘凑华,林建,代刊,韦青,赵声蓉,2024.2019—2021年北京春季温度预报的精细化检验评估[J].气象,50(11):1397-1408.
LI Nina,LIU Couhua,LIN Jian,DAI Kan,WEI Qing,ZHAO Shengrong,2024.Refined Evaluation of Spring Temperature Forecast in Beijing During 2019-2021[J].Meteor Mon,50(11):1397-1408.